Who owns this photoMan or Monkey?
When a monkey takes a selfie, who owns it?
A series of self-portraits taken by Indonesian monkeys has sparked a dispute. It's between Wikipedia and a British wildlife photographer. He wasn't amused that the popular images are being used for free.
This is called a copyright dispute. A copyright is the right to ownership. The creator (for instance, the photographer of a picture or the author of a book) can receive compensation for their effort.
Photographer David Slater complained that Wikipedia rejected his requests for the images to be removed from the website. He said he owns the copyright to the images of crested black macaque monkeys. The pictures were taken in the Indonesian jungle in 2011.
Slater told the BBC that although the monkeys pressed the button, he had set the self-portraits up. He framed them and set the camera on a tripod.
"It required a large input from myself," he said.
But Wikimedia Foundation, the group behind the free information-sharing site, argued that Slater didn't own the copyright to the photos because he didn't take the images.
It said no one owned the copyright to the images, because under U.S. law, "copyright cannot vest in non-human authors" the monkeys in this case. "When a work's copyright cannot vest in a human, it falls into the public domain. We believe that to be the case here."
Wikimedia's spokeswoman Katherine Maher said Slater requested the photos' removal in January. The images are currently free for use and downloading at Wikimedia Commons, the group's database of images and video clips.
Slater said copyright laws should be updated to address cases like his.
Critical thinking challenge: If Slater wins, who loses?