Van Gogh Museum suggests artist's last painting has long been misidentified Vincent van Gogh, "Tree Roots," 1890. (Public domain)
Van Gogh Museum suggests artist's last painting has long been misidentified
Lexile

Assign to Google Classroom

It’s easy to see why many art lovers are quick to identify “Wheatfield With Crows” as Vincent van Gogh’s last painting. The scene screams tragedy. That's because of the darkening storm clouds visible on the horizon. And because of the staccato brushstrokes of the painting’s birds.

But a major piece of evidence contradicts this attribution. The evidence is a letter written by the Post-Impressionist. It dates the work’s creation closer to July 10, 1890. That is a full two-and-a-half weeks before he died. That's according to Zachary Small reporting for Hyperallergic. Researchers from Amsterdam’s Vincent van Gogh Museum now believe that a lesser-known canvas was actually the artist’s final work. That painting is titled “Tree Roots.”

The shift in thinking isn’t an entirely new development. Art historians Bert Maes and Louis van Tilborgh made a convincing argument for the painting’s place in van Gogh’s works. That was in 2012. They point out that “Tree Roots” is one of only two unfinished works dating to the artist’s final days. Van Gogh rarely left canvases incomplete. That's according to Small.

A 2016 show further reinforced the attribution. It was staged at the Van Gogh Museum. The painting’s wall text explicitly identified “Tree Roots” as van Gogh’s likely last work. Curators were eager to dismiss “sensational interpretations” of “Wheatfield with Crows” as a showcase of the artist’s inner strife. That was from a review for the Guardian. It was written by Jonathan Jones.

By emphasizing “Tree Roots” over the better-known work the museum revealed how its “jagged strokes, expressive unreal colors … and empty areas of canvas are just as suggestive as those menacing crows.” That is what Jones argued.

Hyperallergic’s Small details several additional arguments for “Tree Roots”’s true place in van Gogh’s works. Some researchers believe the artist’s style grew more disjointed toward the end of his life. They believe his style embraced abstraction. This was to an extent unseen in earlier works. 

Indeed, the subject of “Tree Roots” is decidedly harder to discern. That is compared to “Wheatfield With Crows” or “Farms Near Auvers.” It is the only other unfinished work produced during van Gogh’s final months. He spent that time in the French village of Auvers-sur-Oise.

Theo van Gogh’s brother-in-law was Andries Bonger. He identified “Farms Near Auvers” as van Gogh’s last work. That was in an 1891 statement. He later highlighted an entirely different canvas. This is what he wrote: “The morning before his death, [van Gogh] had painted a sous bois,” or forest scene. It was “full of sun and life.”

This description fits “Tree Roots.” It breaks from the ominous tone of “Wheatfield With Crows.” It offers a palette filled with a sea of subdued blues. It features greens and browns. 

“The roots have been laid bare, torn from the earth. And hanging perilously,” said senior researcher Louis van Tilborgh. He is co-author of a 2012 article rabout “Tree Roots.” He explained this for a 2016 Van Gogh Museum video. It analyzed the painting.

In some ways, the painting appears to function as a goodbye. Van Tilborgh suggested an interpretation for the message of the work.  He said it's van Gogh's way of saying: “I have lived, just like those tree roots. I’ve done my best. I’ve struggled with life. I’ve grown, had setbacks. And now is the time it ends. I am falling."

The artist's personal correspondence certainly follows Tilborgh's nature-based metaphor. On July 10, 1890, van Gogh wrote letter to his brother Theo and wife Jo. In the letter he said, “I usually try to be quite good-humoured, but my life, too, is attacked at the very root. My step also is faltering.”

Filed Under:  
Assigned 55 times
CRITICAL THINKING QUESTION
Why do you think that people long believed that “Wheatfield With Crows” was Vincent van Gogh's final painting?
Write your answers in the comments section below


COMMENTS (6)
  • Alyssa-E2
    4/05/2019 - 10:59 a.m.

    There dates are very precise and I can't believe that his last painting was two-&a-half weeks before he died, I thought it would be closer like the day of his death. I was right! It wasn't his final work because "Tree Roots," was!I hope he did know he was going to die and that he was saying goodbye, that would be nice.

  • JacobH-dec
    4/10/2019 - 12:21 p.m.

    People thought the painting was the final because they thought it seemed like a goodbye. They think he is saying " I have been through it. I have lived. I have struggled with life. "

  • BelaggioC-dec
    4/10/2019 - 12:29 p.m.

    This was a cool and depressing but he was always depressed.

  • Sabina-E2
    4/10/2019 - 07:41 p.m.

    I think that this is amazing!!!
    We just watched a video in art yesterday about him.
    I am so curious to find out more about his life.
    I’ve never even seen that painting before and I think it should deserve more recognition than what it has now.

  • Sophiac-hug1
    5/08/2019 - 02:04 p.m.

    His art is so cool!

  • GraceR-dec
    5/24/2019 - 08:18 a.m.

    Because that painting was a full 2 and a half weeks before he died so many people think that was his last painting. In my eyes its not he could have painted something else, and the painting might not have went famous, or he might have not finished.

Leave a comment
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Leave a comment