The oldest known butterflies existed before flowers A butterfly perches on a bush. (Cristian Ungureanu/Flickr/USEPA)
The oldest known butterflies existed before flowers

Assign to Google Classroom

Butterflies and moths have a long, tongue-like mouthpiece. It is known as a proboscis. It helps them slurp up tasty nectar from floral tubes. There is a common (and very logical) theory about this handy appendage. The theory states that butterflies and moths evolved their proboscises in response to plants that developed flowers. But that theory might be wrong. That's according to Ben Guarino of the Washington Post. A new study has uncovered evidence suggesting that butterflies and moths had proboscises millions of years before flowers came into existence.

An international team of researchers discovered the fossilized remains of tiny scales. These scales coat the bodies of butterflies and moths. Researchers made this discovery while studying fossil cores. They dated to the late Triassic and early Jurassic periods. 

Timo van Eldijk can push 70 scales beneath a microscope. He used a needle tipped with a human nostril hair. He is graduate student at Utrecht University. It is in the Netherlands. 

“The nose hair has just the right length and springiness for getting a pollen grain to adhere to it. But in this case, the goal is a the butterfly scale.” That's what van Eldijk told Nicholas St. Fleur of the New York Times. “I was just provided these by my professor. I don’t know whose nose hair it was. It’s probably best not to ask.”

Van Eldijk then set about analyzing the structure of the scales. Some were solid and compact. This is not particularly unusual. Previous research has shown that this structure was typical of early moths and butterflies. They used mandibles to chomp their food. But van Eldijk was surprised to discover something else. The scales were hollow. This is a feature only seen among moths and butterflies with proboscises.

“If you find the hollow scales,” van Eldijk told Rebecca Hersher of NPR, “you know the innovation of the proboscis must have occurred before that.”

This discovery was described recently in the journal Science Advances. It threw researchers for a loop. That's because the scales are about 200 million years old. This makes them the oldest known Lepidoptera remains by about 10 millions years. Previous molecular studies on the creatures suggest a similar early evolution of proboscis-bearing butterflies and moths. That's according to Fabien Condamine. He is a butterfly researcher who was not involved in the study. 

The fossils are also about 70 million years older than the first flowers, raising questions about the evolution and function of the proboscis. It is possible that there is simply a gap in the fossil record, and flowers existed earlier than scientists thought. But the study authors believe the more likely explanation is that butterflies and moths evolved their proboscises before flowers came into being. This possibly helped them lap up the sugary pollination drops produced by gymnosperms. These are the most common group of plants that sprung from the ground during the Jurassic.

Filed Under:  
Assigned 260 times
What surprised the scientists about the discovery?
Write your answers in the comments section below

  • ellyb-orv
    1/24/2018 - 02:54 p.m.

    I think that it is cool that butterflies lived longer then flowers.

  • Rhiannonc-bru1
    1/24/2018 - 04:36 p.m.

    The thing that surprised the scientists is that the butterflies and moths lived a lot longer than flowers did and that they had a mouth-like piece that sucked up the nectar from the flowers when flowers came into existence.

  • calliy-orv
    1/24/2018 - 10:31 p.m.

    i learned a lot more about butterflies and they were things that i didn't know about before and this artical was very interesting to me and i hope that i get to read or research about butterfly more like in a project maby or something we could do in class and hopefully i do not forget about it.

  • averym-orv
    1/25/2018 - 10:47 a.m.

    That's cool to discover a fossil that is about 70 million years older than the first flowers. what surprised the scientists about the discovery was the butterfly was around longer than the first flower and it raises eyebrows about the evolution and function of the proboscis.

  • ethanm-orv
    1/26/2018 - 10:12 a.m.

    that is crazy that butterflies were around during the time of the dinosaurs.

  • jackiek-orv
    1/26/2018 - 11:32 a.m.

    that is interesting I didn't think butterflies would have proboscis before flowers.

  • WADEC-vms
    1/26/2018 - 01:06 p.m.

    This is a very interesting article about how butterflies floral tubes were not always like how they are today. It informed me very much on how butterflies actually chewed on food instead of just slurping up some food from a flower.

  • holdenj-orv
    1/30/2018 - 02:52 p.m.

    Its like that skull found in that Israeli cave

  • LizziM-dec
    1/31/2018 - 08:09 a.m.

    It is good they are finding out more about butterflies.

  • TannerT-dec
    1/31/2018 - 08:14 a.m.

    I think what surprised the scientists was that butterflies and moths had proboscises before flowers have existed. I think that way because we always thought butterflies have evolved to suck up the pollen with their proboscis, and now we found out that butterflies and moths had proboscises before flowers even were created.

Take the Quiz Leave a comment