Assign to Google Classroom
There's a big string attached to New York's free middle-class college tuition initiative. Students must stay in the state after graduation. Otherwise, they must pay back the benefit.
Democratic Gov. Andrew Cuomo said that the requirement was added to protect the state's investment in a student's education. The requirement ensures they don't take advantage of free tuition and then leave New York. The rule wasn't a part of Cuomo's free college tuition proposal when he unveiled it. That was in January. It was inserted during final negotiations with lawmakers over the state budget.
The tuition initiative, which Cuomo said is a national model, covers state college or university tuition. It is for in-state students from families earning $125,000 or less. Students must remain in New York for as many years as they received the benefit. They must repay the money as a loan if they take a job in another state.
"Why should New Yorkers pay for your college education and then you pick up and you move to California?" Cuomo said. "The concept of investing in you and your education is that you're going to stay here and be an asset to the state. If you don't want to stay here, then go to California now. Let them pay for your college education."
Students at University at Albany aren't so sure.
"I don't know how much I like feeling confined, even to staying in the state for four more years," said Bobby Rickard. He is an 18-year-old freshman. He is from Brewster. Rickard has not yet decided his major. "I don't know what life will have for me."
Cumorah Reed is a 19-year-old English major. She said certain technology jobs are concentrated on the West Coast. Many of her classmates will be surprised to learn they will not be able to apply for those positions immediately after graduation.
"I think it's going to be harder than people think," Reed said.
Ashley Mendez, 18, a journalism and communications major, said the proposal is a fair compromise. Many residents will stay anyway, she said.
"I'm a New Yorker. I wouldn't leave the state for anything," Mendez said.
Sara Goldrick-Rab is a Temple University professor. She studies college affordability, said the requirement undercuts the promise of free tuition. She said it could deliver a nasty shock to students who fail to read the fine print. Or to students who take the money believing they will stay in New York, only to find better job opportunities elsewhere.
"It's absolutely bait and switch," she said. "You entice people with something they really, really need and then you penalize them if they can't find a decent job and have to leave."
Republican lawmakers pushed for the requirement during closed-door state budget negotiations.
"We took the governor's original plan and made it better, by requiring students to maintain a certain GPA and to live and work in New York after they graduate," said Scott Reif. He is a spokesman for the Senate's Republican leadership.
Students who receive free tuition and then leave the state for an advanced degree won't have to pay the money back assuming they return to New York once they complete their graduate studies. State officials also plan to make accommodations for graduates who leave the state for military service.
As part of the budget, lawmakers also approved a new tuition assistance program for students at private colleges and universities. It offers up to $3,000 in tuition grants. That assistance also comes with a requirement that a student remain in New York after graduation for the same number of years they received the benefit.
CRITICAL THINKING QUESTION
What if college were free in all 50 states?
Write your answers in the comments section below