Americans love an underdog In this 2012 file photo, members of Lehigh's basketball team celebrate after winning an NCAA tournament second-round college basketball game against Duke (AP photo / Thinkstock)
Americans love an underdog
Lexile

It's the time of year for March Madness. And boy, do fans love the underdog. The science shows, again and again, that we can't resist pulling for the underdog teams when college basketball's national tournament rolls around.

About a dozen studies over the past 25 years have shown, in one way or another, that sports fans are inexorably drawn to the team with the odds stacked against it.

"It's the prominent narrative in sports," said Nadav Goldschmied of University of San Diego. He collaborated on one of the studies.

This penchant runs counter to almost everything else we're wired to think. Scientific studies show people want to be associated with success. Our self-esteem grows when we're part of the "in" crowd. Walk one well-dressed job candidate through the door, then follow him up with a schlub. The studies show the majority of us favor the person who appears more attractive. That is almost regardless of their credentials.

But take that same dynamic into a sporting contest like the NCAA basketball tournament. Put a No. 14 seed against a No. 3. Perceptions change.

One of Goldschmied's studies had people watch a basketball game between two relatively unknown European teams after reading different write-ups about the rivalry. One group was led to believe Team A had won the last 15 meetings. The other was led to believe Team B had won all those games. Who they rooted for tilted based on who they considered the underdog.

In both cases, the team perceived as the underdog was viewed as the team giving more effort with less ability.

"That's just the story we tell ourselves," Goldschmied said. "We don't have to look too deep to figure it out."

But it's not always true.

Another study conducted by an Ohio State professor showed that groups that felt they had more to lose actually tried harder. That basically tears apart the whole theory that the Lafayettes, Stephen A. Austins and Hamptons of the world put more on the line in this year's tournament than Kentucky, Kansas and Wisconsin.

In this study, college students were asked to perform a simple task. They were told a group of students from another specific college was doing the same work.

In the studies where one of the competing schools was listed appreciably higher in the U.S. News and World Report college rankings, the students from that school completed about 30 percent more of the task. In short, they worked harder than when they were competing against a college ranked better or equal to theirs.

Conclusion: "The motivation gains were there when students felt their group's superior status was threatened," said the study's co-author, Robert Lount. He's a professor at Ohio State's Fisher College of Business.

"We came at it from a completely different angle. Which was, we know we like to avoid losing more than we appreciate the joy of winning," Lount said. "If you think of your own team as favored, the team may work especially hard to make sure it comes out on top."

For all our love of underdogs, there are a few exceptions.

If a person has a specific rooting interest in a team say the college they graduated from they tend to favor that team. It doesn't matter if the team isn't the underdog.

It helps explain a study that found when big-conference teams are seeded better in games against mid-majors in the tournament, the point spread for the big-conference teams is inflated. It's usually by an average of about two points a game.

"You look at the power conferences, and you see their following is much stronger than those of the smaller schools," said the study's co-author, Jim Lackritz. He is a statistics expert at San Diego State. "People put their money where their hearts are and that drives the line up."

All of which could serve as good advice for people picking against point spreads.

The majority of us though, will fill out brackets with no point spreads involved. Our picks are more based on feel and feeling. Many will pay scant attention to the fact that double-digit seeds have won a mere 41 of 172 games during the opening week less than 24 percent over the past five years. These numbers do not include 2015.

Seems like more, doesn't it?

Well, we're wired to remember it that way.

Quick quiz: Who won the fight at the end of the first "Rocky" movie?

Answer: Apollo Creed.

But in a study Goldschmied is currently conducting, he said a majority of those asked answered "Rocky."

"We will bend our memory," Goldschmied said. "We have forced our memory to change just to fit the underdog story. It's because of the underdog mode in all of us."

Critical thinking challenge: Why do people like to root for the underdog?

Assigned 172 times


COMMENTS (96)
  • JU00baseball
    3/26/2015 - 08:41 a.m.

    I think both teams have a fifty fifty chance of winning it all depends on whos doing good and if your shots are falling, you just got to walk in to the game with the right mind set. i think if you have confidenc then you will give yourself a better chance of winning.

  • cm2001Rosay
    3/26/2015 - 08:43 a.m.

    They like to root for the underdog because the opponent the one everyone is expecting to win always takes it easy on the underdog but they always lose

  • dc2000blue
    3/26/2015 - 08:44 a.m.

    This article is about American liking underdogs. Alos that the basketball team are having a torurments. LAst thing is that they talked about Apollo Creed winning at the end of the first Rocky.

  • 21cdhedm
    3/26/2015 - 12:19 p.m.

    America dose love an underdog. but i personally want Michigan st to win the tournament and make the final four. I think it will be state Kentucky and like Oregon and some gulf coast team

  • 21cdhedm
    3/26/2015 - 12:20 p.m.

    America dose love an underdog. but i personally want Michigan st to win the tournament and make the final four. I think it will be state Kentucky and like Oregon and some gulf coast team

  • 21mmrobi
    3/26/2015 - 12:22 p.m.

    I love basketball. I have played since the 5th grade so not that long but it is still my favorite sport. This year i got on the travel team. It was a lot of fun.

  • 21mmcrow
    3/26/2015 - 12:23 p.m.

    I always liked an underdog because you really don't think much of them and then all of sudden they do something awesome. An underdog in basketball is something that everyone who loves basketball can adore. I really liked this article and I think you will too.

  • ce2001blue
    3/26/2015 - 01:04 p.m.

    People like to root for the underdog because they know that maybe it will strive them to do better and became better and get up there.

  • makaylar-Che
    3/26/2015 - 01:51 p.m.

    because that team was winning all those games so people will cheer for that team no matter what because they want that team to win I'm a duke fan so ill cheer for them not because they are number 1 because I was with that since I was 12 years old and now I'm still cheering for them because I love that team.

  • tylerf-Che
    3/26/2015 - 01:51 p.m.

    I love an underdog because it is very nice to see a team lose to a top 25 team but you know north Carolina will beat Wisconsin tonight I will tell you guys

Take the Quiz Leave a comment
ADVERTISEMENT