Teen finds meaning in 1950s popularity guide
Teen finds meaning in 1950s popularity guide This book cover image shows "Popular: Vintage Wisdom for a Modern Geek," by Maya Van Wagenen
Teen finds meaning in 1950s popularity guide
Lexile: 1150L

Assign to Google Classroom

Respecting or learning from one's elders isn't exactly a top priority for most teens. They're too busy texting or mastering the latest social media platform to relate to the idea that their grandparents ever battled teenage issues like acne or fitting in.

For Maya Van Wagenen, though, digging up a previous generation's teen scene actually helped her. She survived the middle-school blues thanks to "Betty Cornell's Teenage Popularity Guide," published in 1953. Her experiences following the guide led Van Wagenen to write her own book, "Popular," which has now been optioned for a movie.

Van Wagenen, 15, says her father found Cornell's book in a thrift shop, way before she was born. He held onto it for years because its outdated gems like "Beautiful hair is about the most important thing a girl has," made him smile.

The guide surfaced during a clean-up effort and her parents challenged their eighth grade daughter to an idea: Follow the book's advice in secret and write about what happens.

Van Wagenen says considered herself to be "one step above substitute teachers" on her school's popularity scale and worried the project would make things worse.

"It didn't seem like a good idea at all," she recalled in a recent interview. "I was terrified because flipping through the pages you read about all teens must wear a girdle and wear pearls to school and wear pantyhose and red lipstick and stuff that I definitely wasn't comfortable doing."

Although she was used to being invisible, as she read the book she had an epiphany.

"I realized I did want friends and I did want to be liked and I did want to be accepted and while I didn't have a clear cut definition of popularity, I knew that it wasn't what I was. More than anything, I didn't have anything to lose, so I said, 'You know what? I'll try it for a month.'"

She began to make changes, wore pearls, dressed up and even tried a girdle.

Little things suggested by Cornell began to make sense.

Before the "Popularity Guide," Van Wagenen says she'd spend five minutes on her hair. Following the book, she began to put time into her appearance, and a classmate commented that she'd "finally dropped the stupid ponytail."

Some reaction to her new habits was hurtful, but documenting it seemed to help.

"There were times people would say mean things and it would make me feel really bad," confessed Van Wagenen, who was a 13-year-old eighth-grader in Brownsville, Texas, at the time. But writing about them turned them into "hilarious stories" where she was "able to laugh at these things that were genuinely hurtful at first."

"These bullies became characters, and I became a character as well and that was really empowering," Van Wagenen said, adding: "I would say, 'Well, what would I want my character to be doing right now?'"

Besides changing her appearance, Cornell's guide also encouraged Van Wagenen to reach out to others and be more outgoing.

As she made connections, kids began to gravitate to her. Soon she realized, "Everyone around you is like you, and they're looking for friendship, and so it's good to step up and to be that person, that kind person."

As Van Wagenen's experiment was working, her father went to work to track down Betty Cornell, now 79 and living in Audubon, Pa. The two met and Van Wagenen discovered that Cornell still follows the principles of the book herself.

"It was wonderful to share that connection. She said it was great to have her work validated," Van Wagenen said.

Van Wagenen's experiment has just been published in a memoir called "Popular: Vintage Wisdom for a Modern Geek" (Dutton Juvenile), geared to seventh graders and up. "Betty Cornell's Teenage Popularity Guide" has been re-issued as a companion book, and Cornell also wrote the forward to "Popular."

Hollywood also likes Van Wagenen's story: She's optioned the movie rights to DreamWorks.

Van Wagenen, now in 10th grade and living with her family in Statesboro, Ga., speaks with a confidence and wisdom that seems beyond her years. She still breaks out the pearls on special occasions because they're "empowering," but there's one thing she's not keeping: the girdle.

"I definitely left the girdle in the drawer," she said.

Critical thinking challenge: Which tips from the 1950s still apply today? Which ones dont?

Source URL: https://www.tweentribune.com/article/teen/teen-finds-meaning-1950s-popularity-guide/

Filed Under:  
Assigned 20 times

  • colleenl-Ste
    4/30/2014 - 01:20 p.m.

    I think that I might want to read a kind of book like this one or even see the DreamWorks movie production of the book. The fact that this girl went vintage in the 2000's is pretty daring and it takes a lot of courage.

  • EmilyKne
    4/30/2014 - 01:32 p.m.

    It is crazy how many things are still similar. Despite the change of times a lot of things are similar. At the same time though, a lot of things are different.

  • brynnd
    4/30/2014 - 01:55 p.m.

    I think it is a cool idea to write a book about all the bullying and high school experiences girls and boys will go through. If a lot of teens read this, then they can prepare themselves for the high school bullies.

  • Alexbice7
    4/30/2014 - 02:15 p.m.

    I actually didn't know about things being the same, but to be honest I don't want to be popular I think it's stupid and I would rather be a person that speaks there mind and acts like an idiot than be like someone that's not me.

  • NakoomaKewenvoyouma-Lar
    5/01/2014 - 11:57 a.m.

    One of those tips that still apply today are spending time on your hair, I do spend quit some time on my hair and it seems that girls do the same also. Them when you get dressed try to dress out so you get noticed like your own style, so you will be recognized. I really want to see the movie because it seems really interesting and to see it would be wonderful. It seems that back then for teenagers it really wasn't that different to try and be popular.

  • Deishia
    5/02/2014 - 07:52 a.m.

    Girls now day don't really wear purls ,nor do they wear pantyhose .why because theres been a lot of other neat things created .But on a good note kids still wear red lipstick.

  • toryhernandez
    5/02/2014 - 07:57 a.m.

    Some tips you could use today is to have confidence in your appearance. What you wear shows what character you are and helps you express yourself. I don't agree with the whole "fitting in" tips that they give you in the passage. They're there to help guide you and give you ideas, you don't have to follow every single one they give you. It is your decision and up to you on what you want to wear .

  • OrlandoM
    5/02/2014 - 08:08 a.m.

    Some of the tips that still apply today are the ones like appearance and clothing. Definitely not the girdle but they do apply. The jewelry doesn't apply that much any more either. Some jewelry does apply like piercings and stuff like earing as well they do. I don't know to much about the necklaces they do apply in some way though.

  • charlie101
    5/02/2014 - 10:14 a.m.

    Tips from the 1950s still apply today because now we are going back to the vintage clothing back then. They kept it classy that time around and in 2014 we need it to be like that. Most of the 1950s like clothing, jewelry and life style are rare. Some don't apply like haven to be dressing like the 50s. Talking or acting like it.

  • Mark126
    5/02/2014 - 10:18 a.m.

    the outgoing part of the book still applies today I'm not sure if the fashion still is the same because I'm a male and don't really involve myself in it.

Leave a comment
Leave a comment