Big bang claim fizzles out (Thinkstock)
Big bang claim fizzles out
Lexile

A group of scientists made headlines last March. They announced that they'd found evidence about the early universe. But now, they are abandoning that claim.

New data show that their cosmic observations no longer back up that conclusion.

The original announcement caused a sensation. It appeared to show evidence that the universe ballooned rapidly a split-second after its birth. Scientists call it cosmic inflation. That idea had been widely believed. But researchers had hoped to bolster it. They were looking for a particular trait in light. It would have been left over from the very early universe.

That signal is what the researchers claimed they had found. They had taken observations of the sky from the South Pole. The project is called BICEP2.

But now, "We are effectively retracting the claim," said Brian Keating. He is with the University of California, San Diego, a member of the BICEP2 team.

"It's disappointing," he said. "But it's important to know the truth."

The new analysis was conducted by BICEP2 researchers. They collaborated with scientists who worked with the European Planck satellite. The satellite provided new data. It helped interpret the original observations.

In essence, Keating said, the analysis shows that the source of the signal observed by BICEP2 isn't necessarily the very early universe. Instead, it's equally likely to have come from dust in our galaxy. That would mean it does not provide the evidence BICEP2 had claimed.

That possibility had been raised by other scientists. When the BICEP2 team published its results last year, it acknowledged it might have been fooled by the dust. But it still stood by its initial conclusions.

Keating said the search for the signal from the early universe would continue. And the new analysis has helped, he said. It showed how to avoid being misled by the galactic dust.

Critical thinking challenge: Why was it important for the scientists to retract their claim?

Assigned 32 times


COMMENTS (35)
  • Noah_pierce2000
    2/06/2015 - 09:55 a.m.

    I Think that they had to retract it because there is a chance that it is not true and you do not want the public to be freaking out if it might not be even true.

  • GrahamR
    2/06/2015 - 09:55 a.m.

    Scientist are now learning that the claim they made about having evidence of an early universe is false. They are abandoning that claim. Scientist had taken observations in the sky of the South Pole. The Scientist were fooled by some early dust that was found while researching.

  • Tylerrrm
    2/06/2015 - 09:55 a.m.

    It is important because if the claim it they get all the credit.

  • MiahP2018
    2/06/2015 - 09:57 a.m.

    It was important for the scientists to retract their claim because although it may have been nice to have something to believe in, the truth would be better to believe in. The truth may take some time to find, but when it is discovered, it will all be worth it.

  • Kameryn3333
    2/06/2015 - 09:59 a.m.

    It is important for scientist to retract their clam so they are able to figure out the truth.

  • kenzies15
    2/06/2015 - 10:00 a.m.

    It was important for scientists to retract their claim because they were finding out the truth and some things they found out wasn't what they expected.

  • Mikenator
    2/06/2015 - 10:00 a.m.

    Because it wasn't the truth. They need to face it, the big bang didn't happen, and it was created by God.

  • 20ethan18
    2/06/2015 - 10:01 a.m.

    because the scientist found new information and discovered that what they use to believe was inncorrect

  • CourtneyMahone
    2/06/2015 - 10:01 a.m.

    It was important for the scientists to retract their claim because they need to have support before they release something to the public.

  • lexleigh2018
    2/06/2015 - 10:01 a.m.

    It was important for the scientists to retract their claim because their cosmic observations no longer back up the conclusion. It's likely to have come from dust in our galaxy.

Take the Quiz Leave a comment
ADVERTISEMENT